Back to blog
    Zakelijk

    Recognising suspicious payslips

    Check consistency, period and provenance of income evidence. A discrepancy calls for explanation, not an accusation of fraud. An authorised source can improve traceability.

    Author: Thomas de BruinPublisher: CreditCheck.nl6 min reading time
    Smiling candidate in a bright home

    Short answer

    Check consistency, period and provenance of income evidence. A discrepancy calls for explanation, not an accusation of fraud. An authorised source can improve traceability.

    Start with a question, not a dossier

    Digital documents can be altered, but formatting issues may result from exports or administration. Start with substantive consistency and treat the candidate respectfully.

    A check is not a judgment of character or a payment guarantee. First define what you need to know and why it matters to the agreement. Then consider whether the same purpose can be achieved with less data. A convenient form does not establish lawful processing: the requester must justify necessity, transparency and retention in their own process. CreditCheck.nl does not lend or provide legal or financial advice.

    A careful process in five steps

    1. Define the purpose. Describe the transaction, the party and the information actually needed. Avoid requests for every detail of someone's finances.
    2. Set criteria in advance. Apply the same relevant criteria to comparable applications. Do not change them retrospectively because a person is not your preferred choice.
    3. Check source and period. A document date may differ from the period covered by a figure. Record the source, reference date and limitations for each result.
    4. Allow explanations and corrections. A discrepancy or missing item may have an administrative cause. Ask before attaching a consequence to it.
    5. Decide yourself and minimise storage. Retain necessary results only, restrict access and delete data when the reason for retention ends.

    Practical points

    Compare the reporting period, gross or net amounts and supplementary payments. Check that documents actually cover the same timeframe. Request an appropriate alternative if uncertain; do not secretly approach employers or banks or routinely demand full bank statements.

    ItemCareful approachWhat cannot be concluded
    Identity or company registrationMatch the correct party and sourceRegistration does not establish ability to pay
    Income or financial figuresUse comparable periods and clear definitionsOne figure cannot guarantee future payments
    Register resultConfirm identity, publication type and reference dateNo match does not eliminate every risk
    DeclarationIdentify its author and the questions askedA declaration is not an independently verified full picture
    Missing informationAsk for a relevant alternative or explanationRefusal does not establish fraud or unreliability

    An example without a score

    A fictional rent of €1,100 and a requester’s three-times-rent criterion produces a displayed requirement of €3,300. Fictional net income of €3,400 exceeds it, but is not an overall verdict. First establish whether the criterion is appropriate and which reporting period applies.

    This example is fictional. Its amounts and circumstances are not advice, a statutory threshold or a universal acceptance rule. A report can display a factual comparison, but the requester must assess whether the criterion is relevant, proportionate and lawful. Combine the information with the agreement, payment terms and specific circumstances. Discuss uncertainty with a qualified professional rather than making one figure the basis of automatic rejection.

    Privacy and fair assessment

    The GDPR applies to information relating to identifiable individuals, including within a company file. Collect no more than necessary and explain the data, purpose and recipients beforehand. Public register access does not permit unlimited copying or redistribution. Where consent is used, it must be freely given, specific, informed and withdrawable; a dependent relationship requires particular care.

    Do not ask about ethnicity, religion, political views, sexual orientation or health for an ordinary affordability assessment. Viewing identity evidence differs from keeping a copy. The Dutch Data Protection Authority explains that an ID copy usually cannot simply be requested or made when buying or renting. Do not add national identifiers, raw bank statements or sensitive personal characteristics as extra reassurance without a concrete lawful and necessary reason.

    Sources, dates and currency

    Distinguish the date of your check from the date of the underlying information. Financial statements cover historical reporting periods; bank-derived results may span only a limited set of months. A reference may later be supplemented or disputed. Disclose missing sections rather than presenting them as favourable findings. A material change may justify reassessment, but does not automatically authorise permanent monitoring of people.

    How CreditCheck.nl fits

    See Tenant check for product details and the fictional report for an illustration of separate results. Company reports are available on request. Tenant and customer checks are in preparation: in the planned process candidates share their own data through a consent link, without a personal credit score. Identity, income and register integrations and legal conditions must be confirmed before launch.

    Early-access registration does not start a check or payment. Never include the candidate's details in that form. People receiving an invitation can read the planned process and rights on For candidates. There is no public people search and no overall verdict on a person for sale.

    Keep the assessment explainable

    Record which question each information item answers. An objective criterion is not automatically appropriate in every situation: explain why it is necessary and apply it consistently. Avoid merging unverified statements with official records as though both have equal evidential value. Separate reported amounts from independently sourced figures and leave an explicit gap when a source is unavailable.

    Review the proposed decision before communicating it. Check whether a person has had a reasonable opportunity to explain differences, whether an alternative can achieve the purpose and whether the outcome relies on an irrelevant characteristic. Make correction routes clear. A transparent workflow is useful to the requester as well as the candidate because it reduces confusion about what a report actually establishes.

    Frequently asked questions

    Is consent always enough?

    No. Purpose, necessity, proportionality, information duties and sector-specific rules must also be assessed. Have the concrete process legally reviewed.

    Does a discrepancy require rejection?

    No. A signal calls for investigation and explanation. A traceable human decision differs from treating a score as a decisive verdict.

    How can the process stay practical?

    Use a short checklist, consistent definitions and clear source attribution. Retain necessary information only and publish an access and correction route.

    Primary sources

    Editorially written on 15 November 2026. Consult current official sources for your situation. General information, not legal or financial advice.

    Business enquiry

    An enquiry is not an order. Do not share personal details of a tenant or customer you wish to check.

    We securely store your enquiry and forward it to HubSpot for the requested follow-up. Unsubmitted text is not stored; only aggregate starts and submissions are counted. Read our privacy policy.